Chad Helminak
Web Producer and Media Relations Manager
(262) 549-0200, Ext. 6012 chelminak@theleague.coop
Pewaukee, Wis. - An independent study by two
Harvard doctoral candidates found that credit unions offer credit cards
that not only have lower rates than banks, but also adhere to policies
that avoid gouging consumers.
Researchers Ryan Bubb and Alex Kaufman reported to the New York Times
that credit unions are already protecting their members from the
unscrupulous practices that a new federal law – the Credit Card
Accountability, Responsibility and Disclosure Act – aims to
prevent other card issuers from continuing.
The study compared credit cards issued by for-profit banks to those
issued by not-for-profit credit unions and found that credit unions:
• Are less likely to charge fees and penalties that the new
act hopes to eliminate, and when they do, they charge less than other
issuers.
• Do not increase the interest rate if the borrower fails to
make a minimum payment on time.
• Charge half (on average) the amount other issuers charge
for exceeding credit limits.
• Offer lower annual fees and longer grace periods than other
cards.
Bubb and Kaufman explained that these practices are unique to credit
unions because “they answer to a different group of owners –
profits not reinvested are paid to member-owners as a
dividend.”
Brett Thompson, President & CEO of the Wisconsin Credit Union
League, says that because the new law will send many for-profit banks
scrambling to devise new ways to drive profits, it’s still up to
bank customers to understand the terms of their cards, read the fine
print and be vigilant to protect their own interests.
“This study supports what we have always said,” Thompson
says. “Wisconsin credit unions look out for the best interests of
their 2.2 million member owners, not just protecting them from
unnecessary costs for credit cards but also on savings, loans, checking
accounts, ATMs and just about every other financial service working
people use.”
“Credit union cards demonstrate that punishing fees are not an
essential ingredient of profitable lending,” Bubb and Kaufman
noted. They suggested any bank that tries to pad its bottom line with
fees will see many customers flee to credit unions or other institutions
that adopt credit union-like practices.
Credit unions’ member-favored pricing and policies typify their
REAL Solutions® initiative, which meets the needs of members and
communities without regard for profit and teaches consumers to save,
avoid financial predators, access low-cost loans, improve
creditworthiness and build wealth.
Christine Henzig, Director of Communications at The Wisconsin Credit
Union League, explains the results of an independent study which found
that credit unions offer credit cards that not only have lower rates
than banks, but also adhere to policies that avoid gouging
consumers.
(Clips are available for download. Follow links below each embedded
video.)